Tariffs as Federal Income
1. Tariff Revenue from Canada, Mexico, and China
Using 2024 U.S. import projections (based on 2023 data from the U.S. Census Bureau and Trading Economics):
Country | 2024 Est. Imports (USD) | Tariff Rate | Revenue Generated |
---|---|---|---|
Canada | $420 billion | 25% | $105 billion |
Mexico | $400 billion | 25% | $100 billion |
China | $500 billion | 10% + 10%* | $100 billion |
Total | $305 billion |
*China’s tariff is assumed to be a phased 10% + 10% (total 20%).
2. Tariff Revenue if Applied to All European Countries (25%)
The U.S. imported $620 billion from the EU in 2023. Assuming 3% growth in 2024:
- 2024 EU Imports: $638 billion
- Revenue at 25% Tariff: $638B × 0.25 = $159.5 billion
Combined Total Revenue (Canada, Mexico, China, EU):
$305B + $159.5B = $464.5 billion
Spending the Extra Tariff Income
1. Trump’s Promised Tax Reductions
Corporate Tax Cuts (21% → 15%)
- Current Federal Corporate Tax Revenue (2023): $425 billion
- Projected Taxable Income (2024): $3.2 trillion
- Revenue Loss: $3.2T × (21% - 15%) = $192 billion
Individual Tax Cuts
- Trump’s 2017 tax cuts reduced individual rates by 1–4%. A similar 2024 cut (assume 10% reduction in revenue):
- 2023 Individual Tax Revenue: $2.6 trillion
- Revenue Loss: $2.6T × 10% = $260 billion
Total Tax Cut Cost: $192B (corporate) + $260B (individual) = $452 billion
Tariff Revenue vs. Tax Cuts: $464.5B (tariffs) ≈ $452B (tax cuts). Nearly fully offset.
2. Other Spending Areas
Area | Est. Allocation (USD) | Purpose |
---|---|---|
Infrastructure | $100 billion | Roads, bridges, 5G networks |
Debt Reduction | $150 billion | Reduce $34 trillion national debt |
Military | $50 billion | Modernize nuclear arsenal, cybersecurity |
Healthcare | $50 billion | Subsidize prescription drugs |
Border Security | $30 billion | Fund wall construction, ICE operations |
Who Pays for the Tariffs?
1. American Consumers
- Historical Data:
- A 2019 study by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York found that 92% of China tariff costs were passed to U.S. consumers via price hikes.
- Peterson Institute for International Economics: U.S. households paid $1,200/year extra due to 2018–2019 tariffs.
- 2024 Estimate:
- Consumer Burden: 85–90% of tariff costs.
- Annual Cost per Household: ~$1,500 (adjusted for inflation).
2. Import Vendors
- Large Corporations: Walmart, Amazon, and Apple absorb 5–10% of tariffs (via supply chain optimization).
- Small Businesses: Absorb 10–15% (lack pricing power).
3. Currency Manipulation
- China’s RMB Devaluation: In 2019, China devalued the RMB by 7% to offset tariffs. A 10% devaluation in 2024 would nullify a 10% tariff.
- Impact: U.S. tariffs become less effective, as Chinese goods remain cheap.
Conclusion
- Tariff Revenue: Up to $464.5 billion could offset Trump’s proposed $452 billion tax cuts, but consumers bear 85–90% of costs.
- Trade-offs: While corporations and individuals gain tax relief, households face higher prices, and U.S.-China trade tensions could escalate via currency wars.
- Historical Precedent: The 2018–2020 tariffs reduced U.S.-China trade by $100 billion/year but failed to revive manufacturing jobs.
Comments
Post a Comment
Please leave you comments